Check Out These Naples Fish Markets and Make Your Own Seafood Dinner!

Where Can I Buy Fresh Seafood?

When talking fish markets near Naples FL, this list compiles the best places that have fresh, on-site markets with everything you are going to need for a night of making your own seafood at home.

Most of these markets also offer dine-in options for the entire family that will most definitely make your stay in one of our Naples vacation rentals an unforgettable culinary experience. 

So sit back, relax, and let us do all the judging for you, so you won’t have to waste time deciding where to look for seafood markets near Naples FL.

Colorful display of fresh cut seafood and greens.
Photo from Shutterstock

Captain Krewe

Their dine-in restaurant offers the same fantastic menu all day long – in a relaxed atmosphere. Here, you can come as you are and enjoy exceptional food. Whether you are coming from 5th Avenue or straight from the beach, you are always welcome. No need to worry, they have a range of exceptional non-seafood options for everyone in your group.

Their market offers the freshest fish and stone crabs available in Southwest Florida. Their fish display case is always stocked with choice filets, fresh shellfish, and of course their famous stone crabs. You can purchase fish to go or have it prepared on-site by their kitchen staff.

Don’t miss the oyster bar! They have a selection of raw oysters that are shucked for you, making a spot at the raw bar a popular destination for locals and visitors alike. Stop by and learn the difference between a Southern oyster and a Prince Edward Island oyster. No, not every oyster is the same!

Swain River

This restaurant is a fresh fish market and an oyster bar. Talk about all in one!

They have been open since 1996 and their concept is pretty straightforward: buy the best fish, sell the best fish, and sell it fast to assure freshness right out of the sea.

If you feel like dining in, their craft menus will definitely appease your appetite. They offer a wide variety of dishes with ingredients right out of their market, so you know you are getting the freshest. Whether lunch or dinner, you can expect a nice and relaxed family environment without sacrificing that beach vibe.

Wynn’s Market

The first version of this classic market, opened in 1963, back when Naples had only 600 people in permanent population. Back then most of the business of this region of Florida ran through Everglades City. 

It is a big market, when you go in just look for the seafood area. They bring freshness to a whole new level. Anything you will need, they will have it. From Salmon by the pound, oysters, shrimp, crab to more expensive cuts like lobster, black grouper, and even sushi. 

Even after you buy from a Naples seafood market, we invite you to walk around this emblematic piece of Naples, where you will be able to see the history from the moment the founder moved from Lakeland, to present time, still managed and operated by the Wynn family.

Plan Your Visit!

Are you ready to discover the freshest seafood options offered in Naples Florida? Plan your visit with us today and browse through luxurious Naples rentals that fit you and your family’s needs!

How to Get Started

If this is your first time preparing fish and seafood at home, you’re in for a real treat. The great thing about fish and seafood is that they can often be prepared in the simplest of ways. This quickly turns them into a great meal, and soon you’ll be eating them more often than you originally thought.

Before you get cooking, let’s look at the basic elements that go into selecting, storing, and cooking fish and seafood.

We already went through the best places to pick up your food. If you don’t plan on cooking right away, storing is also a key step to keep your ingredients fresh. It is not difficult to store fish, but it is different from other meats. To preserve the freshness of your fish, avoid plastic freezer bags and use ice chests instead. The bag method is good for a few days, but not in the long run.

Your store-bought fish may be ready to cook without additional preparation. Often it is enough to season and sear the filet, and the meal is ready. However, if you need to clean the fish, a few extra steps are required. Freshly caught or whole fish must be gutted and scaled. You’ll also need to filet the fish, and if it’s a flatfish, like flounder, a little more care is required.

Once you get over your fear of preparing seafood, you’ll realize how easy it is. When in doubt, just follow a recipe because there are many tasty options just waiting to be discovered.

Seafood is actually very easy and quick to prepare, you just need to know a few tricks. Crustaceans like lobster and crab just need to be cooked. Getting the meat out is more difficult than the actual cooking.

Other seafood like shrimp can be steamed, and shrimp scampi is a popular dish.

Scallops can be easily sauteed. Oysters can be shucked and served fresh or prepared in a delicious dish like these delicious Southern Fried Oysters.

What Can I Make?

Want to make seafood for dinner? There are so many tasty ways to incorporate seafood into your meal prep. It’s a healthy and delicious way to eat lean, filling protein, and the backbone of the Mediterranean diet.

Creamy Shrimp Pasta is an easy-to-make recipe, but you’ll have to balance making three components at once: shrimp, noodles, and sauce. Make perfectly al dente pasta, saute the shrimp, and make the sauce. Once the shrimp is done, make that sauce and you’re good to go! Then mix it all together! Done and done. The ingredients for making the Parmesan cream sauce include salted butter, garlic, flour milk, salt, and parmesan cheese. 

Fish Tacos are always a win! In this recipe, the white fish is baked until it’s flaky with a zingy dry rub of spices, then topped with a tangy slaw and a creamy fish taco sauce. They’re tasty, easy to make, and ideal for weeknights or dinner parties. We recommend tilapia, cod, or mahi mahi for the fish, and the spices in the sauce are sour cream, lime juice and zest, hot sauce, garlic powder, and salt.

Pesto Salmon is a true treat! Bright green pesto goes hand in hand with tender baked fish to make a stunning dinner. The savory, garlicky sauce makes the flaky fish pop,  you’ll already be taking your second bite before finishing the first. For this, you only need these two ingredients, that is if you use store-bought pesto sauce, to make it at home we recommend the following ingredients: fresh basil leaves, pine nuts, garlic, parmesan cheese, olive oil, and salt. 

Where should I stay?

Southwest Florida is a tropical vacation paradise, and Premier Sotheby’s International Realty offers an inventory of the most luxurious rental properties available along the Gulf Coast. At Premier Sotheby’s, we represent Naples beachfront rentals and condominiums, majestic estates, cozy cottages, and resort-style retreats from Naples north along the coast to Bonita Springs and Estero. If you’re looking for a luxurious vacation getaway in a prime location, be sure to browse through our Naples vacation condo options. With a wide variety of Naples condo rentals available, you’re guaranteed to find your perfect vacation match! Another favorite location is our Marco Island vacation rentals, equipped with million-dollar views without the price! When looking through available Marco Island rentals, be sure to check out the popular attractions located in the area! Visitors from around the world enjoy sunsets over the Gulf of Mexico, beach walks, fishing, boating, tennis, golf, fine dining, world-class shopping, and renowned cultural institutions.

Whether you vacation for a week, stay for the entire season or choose an annual rental, experience Southwest Florida’s variety of lifestyles. A golf course community, a waterfront residence, a trendy condo in town, or a private gated enclave, await you in one of our luxurious stays.